The Island is gorgeous! Paradise! The cabin is cute and cozy, bbq is good but here is a list of what we wish we knew:
There was no TP
The Beer and TP at the general store are pretty far up a hilly gravel road and a bike would be necessary (can rent beside the store)
The upstairs bedroom bed is super tiny, child size.
The Outhouse is very very basic, unpainted, broken lamp
Access to the beach is by a walk and some steep path/stairs. If you have a 4 yr old this is important to know.
Would have been 5/5 with the essentials, TP, bikes, outhouse upgrade... but these few snags were the essentials!
We loved the Island but wish the